Foto Quality, not fulfilling acceptance criteria and Ineligible location
andrgr-PGO
Posts: 9 ✭✭
This is a a public playground from the city, I named it „Gorilla Slide playground Hart by Graz“ and described it in the following way „ the public playground also has this exiting gorilla silde. I very often get stops not accepted and cannot understand the reasons. What can be improved? Are these fotos realy bad?
Best Answer
-
Maxyme99-PGO
Posts: 953 ✭✭✭✭✭
You can only have one POI for each playground, so if playground wasn't nominated yet, nominate it as full playground, not just as slide. And if playground is a POI, then your nomination is ineligible, you can't make each equipment on playground as new POI. But you should get dupliactes for it if playground existed as POIs, so it looks like playground still isn't a POI.
Looks like reviewers wanted to tell you that you shouldn't nominate just one equipement from playground, maybe because of that you got rejection for photo quality and inappropriate activity - it's not the best option, but if reviewers wanted to tell you something, they tried with rejection reasons, they don't have any other way to do it. The "not eligible" reason was correct - one equipment from playground isn't eligible, full playground is.
So try nominating playground, and make support photo in a way that will show more area near this place, so people can compare it location to map. you can't really see much from your support photo here.
I also tried to find your playground on map, I found playground I think might be this one, but I;m not 100% it is this one. If it is, then people don't see streetview from side of slide, because there isn't streetview on that street. They got streetview from other street that does show playground, but don't show slide and this playground doesn't look like on your photos on streetview. But I might found different playground, I'm not sure there.
But for sure, nominate full playground, not just one rquipment and it shoul be accepted :)
Answers
Photo quality doesn't seem a correct reason for rejection.
Without seeing the rest of your nomination, it's hard/impossible to comment otherwise. Show screenshots of your actual nomination if you want further help. :)
Maybe text to short?
I can’t see what’s wrong, I would have accepted it. I’m from Belgium and often get to review submissions in Germany (although I don’t speak German), I see this kind of playgrounds a lot and I accept them.
I can understand the bad-quality picture.
In the review bad quality is to be used for blurry, black, in-car or sun-glared pictures. None of these apply to your picture.
But if you nominate a playground, try to make a picture of the entire playground. Your supportive picture is better than the original one. If you ask me to take a picture of you, I zoom in and make a picture which shows only your shoulder. Would you consider it a good picture?
A playground doesnt meet acceptance criteria?
Thanks I see your point, but the stop is the gorilla slide and not the playground, but the answer still is valuable for me for understanding.
You can only have one POI for each playground, so if playground wasn't nominated yet, nominate it as full playground, not just as slide. And if playground is a POI, then your nomination is ineligible, you can't make each equipment on playground as new POI. But you should get dupliactes for it if playground existed as POIs, so it looks like playground still isn't a POI.
Looks like reviewers wanted to tell you that you shouldn't nominate just one equipement from playground, maybe because of that you got rejection for photo quality and inappropriate activity - it's not the best option, but if reviewers wanted to tell you something, they tried with rejection reasons, they don't have any other way to do it. The "not eligible" reason was correct - one equipment from playground isn't eligible, full playground is.
So try nominating playground, and make support photo in a way that will show more area near this place, so people can compare it location to map. you can't really see much from your support photo here.
I also tried to find your playground on map, I found playground I think might be this one, but I;m not 100% it is this one. If it is, then people don't see streetview from side of slide, because there isn't streetview on that street. They got streetview from other street that does show playground, but don't show slide and this playground doesn't look like on your photos on streetview. But I might found different playground, I'm not sure there.
But for sure, nominate full playground, not just one rquipment and it shoul be accepted :)
This is a good explanation I have already one equipment accepted, see picture but not the playground overall. The soccer field on that playground is accepted as well and an arena. So I will try it again with an overall picture and the full playground. It has to be near the gorilla slide otherwise it is in the same cell.
Or there is a beach volleyball court as well. I could also nominate this as a stop. I have to wait for the net to make a picture, was currently removed maybe because of covid19.