About the appeal function
MaxInmelman-PGO
Posts: 25 ✭✭✭
It means that you will be able to appeal the decision of the community, but if the denied one is approved, is there any penalty for the judge who denied the nomination?
At the very least, I would like you to send an email to the judge, such as "Your nominations have been approved as a result of the appeal. Please examine carefully in the future." I don't think it will improve the quality of the judges without feedback.
Comments
Maybe a better way to do this is if we can see the last 100 agreements or disagreements and if something gets overturned have it flagged so it can be seen.
If you want Niantic to do that, then that means Niantic will have to provide ongoing feedback for reviewers. If they want reviewers to improve, it is not sufficieint to say "You got it wrong". Why?
I've been asking for reviewer feedback for a long time - never seen any indication that Niantic will ever provide this.
Hey, new here. Just appealed something and I think some people seriously have the rules wrong.. And nobody's there to tell them..