How can I improve rejected proposal


I had my proposal rejected for these criterias (sometimes when I refresh they are different that's why there are more than 2) :

  • Fake proposal
  • Inapropriate location
  • Abuse
  • Other rejection criteria

Here all the details.

I add the exact location on google maps since the location seems to be the main rejection criteria here (don't know if it's ok to post externals links).

GPS data : 43°55'51.9"N 3°00'19.2"E'51.9%22N+3%C2%B000'19.2%22E/@43.9304773,3.004686,273m/data=!3m1!1e3!4m14!1m7!3m6!1s0x12b233d4491e9cc3:0x1c06f69f78d94ff0!2s12250+Saint-Jean-d'Alcapi%C3%A8s!3b1!8m2!3d43.9616682!4d2.9975593!3m5!1s0x0:0x25da508e57b15c08!7e2!8m2!3d43.9310759!4d3.0053412

Help figure out how to improve this proposal, which is legit and real of course, and totally accessible.

PS: Sorry for my english.


  • MelodyS88Chi-PGOMelodyS88Chi-PGO Posts: 259 ✭✭✭
    edited January 10

    How do you think that meets criteria? Since you just posted the image rather than copying and pasting the description I am totally sure what it says since my French is not 100% fluent, but it looks like just some sort of storm drain or well with a grate over it to prevent large debris from being washed down and/or prevent people from falling if they step on it.

    That is not something that is even close to meeting criteria. The way to improve the nomination is to not renominate it at all and find something else actually eligible to nominate.

    The reasons for rejection may not be the appropriate reasons but the fact that it was rejected is appropriate. It is a just a bad nomination.

  • Dardoked-PGODardoked-PGO Posts: 3

    It's an old well used by farmers a long time ago. The grate is for safety reasons, not a for draining or else. I see a lot of wells as wayspots so I thought it would fit, it is not the fanciest for sure but it is one of a kind in its area, made by humans hundred years ago and very discreet. This an interesting point that I show people when walking by.

    For me the interest is historical and its uniqueness, but if you say it don't meet criterias at all then too bad, I am just doing that to make people discovering things and was just wondering why it has been rejected.

Sign In or Register to comment.