shrine office
burninglawyer-PGO
Posts: 4 ✭✭
Does the shrine office do not meet the approval criteria?
I applied several times but it was rejected.
Shrine office is caiied "Shamusho" in Japanese, There is about to buy amulets and votive tablets, and apply for prayers.
Also, staff menbers of the shrine is stationed here( Like Mikosan or Guujisan in Japanese), and you can get special stamps(These stamps are called "Goshuin". ) and get various consultations on amulets and prayers.
Some staff menbers tell us stories about the shrine.
Isn't this a place where you can interact?
Tagged:
Comments
Can you post example of your rejected nomination?
thank you for your comment.
it rejected by Other Rejection Criteria.
Can you post the nomination so we can see what you're talking about
It's almost the same as what I wrote above.
I wrote in the supplementary explanation that it is a place where you can interact with others.
Sounds like it's a small shop. People don't go there to socialize. Or to exercise. Its purpose is not to let people stream thru exploring it, then leaving.
Generally, we don't have any idea since most of us aren't locals. Specifically, we also don't have idea since we haven't seen your nomination details yet.
Maybe certain Japanese like @tp235-ING can give some insights?
I was called in out of the blue for some reason.
I haven't seen the nominations themselves, so I'm speaking in general terms.
I think it would be difficult for a shrine office to be approved separately from the shrine, as it is actually a fully integrated function of the shrine.
I also think that unless the building of the shrine office is designated as an important cultural asset or has some other added value, it is considered to be a duplicate of the shrine.
However, there were no specific examples given in the nominations around 2014, when the specific approval criteria were vague, and the nominators at that time tended to nominate everything separately, so there may be wayspots of shrine offices that were approved around that time.
何かいきなり呼ばれましたが、ノミネート自体を見ていませんので、一般論になります。
神社の社務所は神社の機能として完全に一体化しているのが実情なことから神社とは別に承認されるのは難しい気がします。
私もその社務所の建物が重要文化財に指定されているなどの別の付加価値が無い限り、神社と重複と判断します。
ただ、具体的な承認基準が曖昧であった2014年頃のノミネートでは具体的な例が示されていなかったこともあり、当時のノミネーターは何でも個別にノミネートする傾向にあったので、その頃に承認された神社の社務所のwayspotは存在するかもしれません。
thanks all.
it seems to be so difficult, I gave up to apply.