Feedback for reviewers is needed
Currently, there is no feedback to reviewers as to how they are reviewing. We can look at some "home made" stats such as the percentage of reviews we have completed that agreed with the community vote, but that in no way links into our Wayfarer rating - you can have an excellent %age score while being "Poor". The whole Wayfare rating scoring system is very opaque and of no help to reviewers if we don't know what we are doing wrong.
I'd like to improve my "correct review" percentage, but in order to do so I need some sort feedback from Niantic. I understand that Niantic want to keep at least some of the criteria "flexible", but without any sort of feedback improvement is difficult. Can Niantic please provide some sort of feedback to reviewers so we can at least see say, the last 10 nominations we looked at where we did not "agree". Niantic don't have to actually specify what exactly is wrong, thus keeping their flexibility, but it might help us with a clue ( "See - I thought that generic Costa Coffee shop should have been rejected"). Given the large discussions about "mass rejections" and "bots", it might also let reviewers pick up on stuff like this quickly and report it to Niantic.
TLDR. Please can reviewers have some feedback on their "errors" from Niantic. YOu get a better Lightship database that way.