URL or Markup - How does this nomination have this rejection?
rufoushumming-PGO
Posts: 1,450 ✭✭✭✭✭
Here I go again.
This is one of several that have been rejcted for URL/Mark up.
It clearly either shows the reviewers are not reviewing. Or and hence the criteria question, am I missing something!
Yes I know. Both had other criteria so i assume exercise/social/explore at play there. But this is about the reason - URL / Mark Up
Tbanks for any guidance!
Title
NotNot Signal Box Art
Rejection Criteria
URL or Markup
Other Rejection Criteria
Description
Street Art by local Bondi artist NotNot. NotNot's real name is Cam Scott, was born in the USA and studied Fine Arts at the University of NSW. He has contributed significantly to the local art scene. His art has been seen from the Bondi Graffit wall to numerous street art including a range of commissioned Traffic Signal Boxes such as this one. His art has also featured in the Sydney MCA and the Venice /Guggenheim Biennale
Example two
Title
Bronte Park Miniature Railway
Rejection Criteria
URL or Markup
Other Rejection Criteria
Description
Miniature Railway Track and Train Shed in Bronte Park. This train has been running since 1947 and was built, opened and is run by Coleman & Sons. The railway is set in Bronte Park which became a public recreation reserve in 1886 and whose general layout remains as it was from the1940s.
Comments
You didn't include supporting text, so I can only guess you had URLs there. If you put a URL in your supporting text, there will be people who wrongly reject it with the URL reason. Still, URLs in supporting text are very useful, so you have to hope you overcome those few bad reviewers. That's all you can do.
@flatmatt-PGO Oh yes. Totally there are urls in the supporting text. That is where I point to supporting links etc to validate historical, place websites, council/government sites. Direct links to supporting google stuff.
Thank you for pointing that out. I had not thought of that. ;-)
Never seen it before. So hey. Cool.
I'm trying to remember what the supporting statement of this looked like. I gave this middle of the line marks since I've seen some of Notnot's art around the Bondi area. The supporting statement had like these uncomfortable "............................." lines between two URLs one linking to Notnot's Instagram. Leave the insane number of fullstops out, state your actual support in a sentence and don't let the URL be your only support, and try not to use more than one URL. Trying to put myself in the shoes of the reviewers here.
You should show the others what your supporting statements look like.