Rule to ban addresses in names
tif3331988-PGO
Posts: 4 ✭✭
Is it prohibited to indicate the house and street number in the application for the portal or pokestop, or is it only prohibited to indicate that this is the house of a particular person (personal data) like the house of a celebrity or other person?
The rule: The name and/or description by type are copied from other sources. In particular, they contain emoticons, tags, or personal information, {such as call signs, personal names, initials, or addresses}.
Comments
private residential homes don't meet the criteria why would anyone put an address in it?
Is the address of the nomination itself in its title a rejection criterion? This is not the address of a specific person, this is the address of the nomination. Is it against the rules? For example: The playground is located next to the building at 7 Baker, and the title of the nomination is "Playground at 7 Baker"
At least it has better title than simply a "playground".
Yes, an option like "playground (address)" or "post office (address)", and not the house itself as a nomination.
I wouldn't call that an address thats more of the location but yes that would be fine to have in the title
If it’s Playground (Ariana Street) that’s fine (think thought Ariana Street Playground would better).
If it is something like Post Office (457 Givenem Road, Wendell Town, West North Yorkshire) then that’s not really a great title but not a reason to reject overly
For example, "Children's Playground Slavskogo 28" is a good nomination, because it is the location, not the address of the nomination itself, and the Museum (Slavskogo 28) is not very good?
Yeah, I would think a museum has a better “identifier” than the road name etc. It may be the Ukrainian Museum of Modern Art (not sure if such a place exists) and adding the road it is on to the title does very little.
However, different identifiers are important for things like trailmarkers (I don’t like them being numbered for no reason).
I don’t think it’s a reason to reject unless really terrible but a lower rating for title, for sure.
You misread the whole thing again. You shouldn't reject nominations if they mention street addresses or names in title/description (unless they contain some certain names/codenames that you strongly feel they refer to another users like this one). For example, some buildings may have their building name given by notable person within the area.
Of course the nominations are still subject to other acceptance or rejection criteria.
As long as "Slavskogo 28 street" is not a single-family private residence, it's perfectly acceptable.