Improve Expreience of Reviewers and Submitters by Feedback
When I started reviewing, I always wrote something for "Additional comments on your decision" so the submitters could improve based on my advice. But as it seems, submitters don't even get to see these additional comments.
To improve the wayfarer expreience for both reviwers and submitters there should be more feedback.
- For submitters: They should see the comments that the reviewers added (maybe you as a reviewer should be forced to write some words so you have to really think about your decision and that the submitters have more information to learn from). Criteria should be easier to understand (-> e.g. rename "Other Rejection Criteria" to "Does not meet eligibility criteria").
- For reviewers: Get actual feedback on your decisions (maybe something like a review-log) so you can improve. Maybe also some clear satements for anyone to see about criteria updates or frequent mistakes (e.g. rejecting trail markers).
Feel free to add your own ideas :)