Beaches - Signs or Beaches?
My friends and I took pictures of the signs 4 times. Failed 4 times.
Should I take pictures of the beach instead?
Best Answer
-
WheelTrekker-ING Posts: 3,387 ✭✭✭✭✭
Existing wayspots are not proper examples of valid wayspots.
Many have been approved under different rules, others might have slipped and been approved although they should have been rejected.
So if you want to argue why some nomination hasn't been approved, don't base your question on "similar ones have been approved",and as @nobbynobbs1st-PGO is telling you, if there's a thread about that wayspot it's useless to open a new one about the same wayspot because you don't like the replies that have been provided.
And lastly: we don't know how the reviewers on your zone think, we don't know your culture, all the rest of the data of your nominations, so don't try to find here a solution for a local problem and be disappointed if we don't grasp the details about your zone.
Answers
Someone asked this already on another thread, I presume it's your second account or a friend.
Top picture looks like a lifeboat station, so not eligible.
Bottom picture looks like a generic, mass produced sign for the do's and don'ts of a beach so again, not eligible.
@nobbynobbs1st-PGO I said “My friends and I took pictures of the signs 4 times”. Yes, he’s my friend.
@NicoSolheim-ING Both pictures say “XXX Beach”. They are the official signs.
Guys, the thing that bugs me is that they are the official signboards put up by the government. If they are not eligible, that’s fine. Should my friends and I take a picture of the beach instead? There are 5 beaches in my area, none of which has a Wayspot.
Beaches would fail as natural features. I'd look for better signs that are less generic.
If one rejects an official sign, it’s their problem, not mine.
But those official signs look like generic, mass produced signs, which why they're not getting through.
Are you saying that all the signs you see in your country are unique?
No, most of the beach signs in my cou try are the same mass produced, don't do this, please call this number in case of emergencies, etc type of signs that shouldn't be approved since they're so generic
Yes , and your friend has already had the same images discussed. Though you didn't get an agreement there so started a second thread. Fairly pointless
@nobbynobbs1st-PGO It’s sad to see a reply like this. I thought we should treat everyone with respect here.
There are many beaches Wayspots in my country. They use(d) similar pictures.
We failed 4 times. This is strange. This is why we want to find an answer, seeking advice from you people.
What was disrespectful?
It's disrespectful to the community to ask a question, not like the answer, so ask it again hoping to get a different one.
This.
Existing wayspots are not proper examples of valid wayspots.
Many have been approved under different rules, others might have slipped and been approved although they should have been rejected.
So if you want to argue why some nomination hasn't been approved, don't base your question on "similar ones have been approved",and as @nobbynobbs1st-PGO is telling you, if there's a thread about that wayspot it's useless to open a new one about the same wayspot because you don't like the replies that have been provided.
And lastly: we don't know how the reviewers on your zone think, we don't know your culture, all the rest of the data of your nominations, so don't try to find here a solution for a local problem and be disappointed if we don't grasp the details about your zone.
My intention was to try to be clear. As the post that my friend made didn’t include pictures in the first place. Anyway, thank you.