"Not Culturally or Historically Significant" - Educational Sign
TheOneAndrew-PGO
Posts: 28 ✭✭
Sorry but this got rejected for not being historically or culturally significant and I fail to see how this is the case, I would like to request any info to improve this please!
Comments
This looks like a temporary info sign on a project that is going to be developed ?
@DeDuckIsDees-ING I disagree. While on first lol it seems like that, it seems to be educating the community about the importance of trees and ecosystems. I would have four-stared for every category, excerpt for the above category, which I would still 3*, because it is good besides that.
did you try re submitting and mentioning how it is important or significant to the community/culture? Id suggest try that. If you resubmit you should be fine
Don't know how to confirm temporary or not but this is the location on Google SV and shows its been there since May?
https://www.google.com/maps/@51.5090536,-0.5847462,3a,84y,354h,84.36t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1swGhCCBE6Hnfgyplaujte3g!2e0!7i16384!8i8192
In fairness, everything in our universe is ultimately "temporary", thanks to entropy. Even the black holes - which will persist for long, long after everything else has "died" - will eventually evaporate away due to Hawking Radiation. That's assuming the universe undergoes a "heat ****" and does not rip itself apart before hand. Having said that, this sign looks like it will linger in our universe for long enough to be accepted as a Wayspot.
I was asking. I wasn’t stating. :)
usually signs are put up to announce a certain project and then they are removed once the project is complete.
that was the first feeling I got when I saw and read it.
and maybe others too which made it be rejected
it looks ok to me but I was just trying to figure out with you what caused the rejection.
It came up in my review list, this one is is a duplicate of an identical sign not that far away.
Thanks for answering for me so I didn't have to look it up on Intel.
"Not culturally significant" and "not visually unique" tend to pop up the most when a candidate could potentially be marked as a duplicate. Some reviewers accept, others flag it as a duplicate, and there is no hard 1* rejection so the system gives it the culture/visual rejection.
Try making a picture of a black hole. Nomination will probably rejected for pitch black photo or unsafe pedestrian access 😅