Invalid Portal Appeal
MaDeinChina-ING
Posts: 15 ✭✭
Title of the Wayspot:兵马俑拿隐形剑
Location: https://intel.ingress.com/intel?ll=31.195155,121.086365&z=17&pll=31.195573,121.084312
City: Shanghai
Country: China
Screenshot of the Rejection Email:
Photos to support your claim:
Additional information:
Refer to the attached photos, there is no any Terracotta sculpture located at the target location(nearby south edge of the production workshop building of Anshuo Culture and Education Utensils (Shanghai) Co., Ltd.).
This portal has been removed permanently or it's a fake portal since no one will put a Terracotta sculpture into production workshop building
Thanks!
Tagged:
Comments
I support the removal for following reasons:
1. The portal does not exist at current location and there is an obvious mismatch between the background of the profile photo and the surroundings on the scene
2. This area is actually the factory of AXUS STATIONERY (SHANGHAI) CO., LTD.
https://cn.kompass.com/c/axus-stationery-shanghai-co-ltd/cn069657/
https://bbs.fobshanghai.com/company/16q0y3612vm7v18.html
https://www.hiredchina.com/companys/axus_stationery_shanghai_company_limited_1489368058935
and is a private factory that does not grant public access. It's weird for a private factory to place such sculpture inside
3. This company was previously known as a world-famous brand "Marco" of Shanghai Marco Stationery Co Ltd https://www.bloomberg.com/profile/company/7964294Z:CH
and the factory on No.111, Xuezi Rd.(S)
Qingpu County 201712 Shanghai is making "marco pencils" which you could find on Amazon
https://www.amazon.com/marco-raffine-colored-pencils/s?k=marco+raffine+colored+pencils
4. Please refer to a video and an article about this factory
https://www.atlasobscura.com/articles/watch-wooden-blocks-transform-into-a-rainbow-of-color-pencils
In the article it says "In the video above, Axus, a stationery factory in Shanghai, China, reveals the steps of the precise process of constructing the perfect color pencil." which proves that it's a factory. And as we all know, no one will put a Terra-Cotta Warriors sculpture into production workshop building of a factory of common sense.
5. Putting sculpture inside a production workshop is a serious violation of ISO-9001 and ACMI standards and risking the business. As a world-famous Producer / Exporter
https://research.hktdc.com/en/article/NjUzNDk3NjQ1
https://www.importgenius.com/colombia/suppliers/axus-stationery-shanghai-company-ltda
https://www.coatings1.com/coating-suppliers/marco-cn
the factory of AXUS STATIONERY just won't do that. It's techinically not possible for there to be sculpture like this. This portal is very likely relocated from somewhere far away.
Imagine you see the sculpture of the portal sitting beside such professional assembly line in the same factory building.
That would be so ridiculous. It's just not possible for portals like this to show up there.
To protect the commercial interests you won't find many results of how the interior of the factory looks like...among those not many, it's just a workshop full of machines leaving no space for sculpture as well:
Have you gone inside the building? If not then you can't be 100% sure that the statue is not there.
Have you? Actually the background of the profile photo of this portal clearly suggests that it's not inside the building.
Photos on the scene shows that it's not there. Please present the proof that the statue really is there then if you insist.
I would suppose every reader on the forum would doubt why such statue locates in a factory full of assembly lines.
This is the profile photo of the portal. Please pay attention to the wall and the very left top corner.
Which means the portal does not exist there.
Dear @NianticGiffard , we've found tangible proof that this portal does not exist:
There is another portal <兵马俑> which is real but is 13KM away.
The portal we requested for removal in this post is a fake portal as a clone of it. The player who submitted the application intentionally ab.use the OPR system and modified the location of the photo.
https://intel.ingress.com/?pll=31.298637,121.148472
The portal 兵马俑 is actually 13KM away which has the same appearance and surroundings, which means "兵马俑拿隐形剑" does not exist on current location.
I just came to say that additionally, simply by looking at the reflection of the window it's obvious those statues are not inside a building.
Then I saw your latest message about the obvious duplicate portal. Nice detective work!
2=1?
Logical thinking told me this is a fake portal with high probability, I thought the latest solid evidence(it was duplicated from a 13KM away portal- https://intel.ingress.com/intel?ll=31.298637,121.148472&z=17&pll=31.298637,121.148472) shall addressed your concern now, is that correct?
The 2nd profile photo of 兵马俑拿隐形剑 vs. 13KM away "兵马俑“ profile photo
Please elaborate your idea clearly.
Are you trying to say that they are different structure in terms of the amount of sculptures and thus this is not a fake/clone portal?
Looking forward to your replies LOL
Interesting...A restaurant inside this factory, just near the production workshop?
Obviously, it's a duplicate Portal of https://intel.ingress.com/?pll=31.298637,121.148472. The position of this Portal has been maliciously modified to someone's factory.
One more thing interesting: Players can barely reach this portal from outside the factory but have to enter the factory zone to reach another portal adjacent to this fake one https://community.wayfarer.nianticlabs.com/discussion/17219/invalid-portal-appeal
which means if someone has been to <ELEPHANT PLAY THE BALL> then he/she must have got a clear picture of whether <ELEPHANT PLAY THE BALL> and <兵马俑拿隐形剑> exist or not.
Player @miclovesisi-ING went there in 2021/Apr along with DyingPhantom according to the public log:
2021-04-09 13:47:18 miclovesisi captured <Elephant Play the Ball>
2021-04-09 13:47:50 DyingPhantom deployed a Resonator on <Elephant Play the Ball>
2021-04-09 13:49:12 miclovesisi deployed a Resonator on <Elephant Play the Ball>
which means miclovesisi very likely knows that these two portals do not exist on the scene. See how he replied in this post.
Dear @NianticGiffard @NianticAaron @NianticCasey-ING , could you please help to look into this thread? Thanks!
Sorry for the delay, we'll have it prioritized.
Thank you!
Thanks for the appeal, Agent. After reviewing the additional evidence provided, we’ve decided to retire the Portal in question.