Aeryle88-PGO
✭✭✭
Comments
-
It's not the trail marker we are supposed to evaluate. Reject trail marker is not good. Niantic should ban reviewer who reject trail marker because theses rejections are against the criteria. The 'generic' fact is not pertinent for trail marker because trail marker are juste a physical objet to attach a POI whitch…
-
The fact that reviewer reject unnamed trail marker won't change the fact Niantic clairly said that they are ok to be a POI. You don't understand that a trail marker is just the physical point to attach the POI to. The thing we are supposed to evaluate is the trail they represented (or at least the sector of the trail where…
-
Not since the last AMA of november 2020 and the criteria refresh ;)
-
You're wrong: Niantic clearly said that there is no need to have the name of the trail to be eligible.
-
There was a sign but it was destroyed years ago by a truck and the equestrian center don't buy a new one because it's obviouly here. (there is a sign but for cars 150m away) There is a marker on google map but the name and the place of the marker is not correct (i suppose the person who own the equestrian center don't…
-
Fake wayspot will always be a problem but it's not specific to rural area. The fact is: the more there are false rejection in rural area, the more a few players in rural area will try to submit a fakestop, in order to play. That's bad and people who fake wayspot should be banned, but i'm sure that is there is less false…
-
there is no sign on the equestrian center. The only sign is far away to indicate direction to cars so it can’t be a wayspot. îm curious to know in witch country people built that in their garden because here in France, every installation like that are a equestrian center open to public.
-
Sorry English is not my native language so sometimes, i misunderstand. Thanks
-
Sorry i became angry because i pass a lot of time to find the best place, to took the better photo i can and to write the better description i can, and every time something is reject for bad and reason reason, i have the sentiment of loosing my time. (and have to wait many weeks to have the proposition re-evaluated after…
-
ok. I don't really see why people want a photosphère. It won't really show anything other that the equestrian center (we already see it on the photo) and the forest aroud the center... but ok. The fact is i explain all what i can in description and in additionnal information. And the first thing people say here is the…
-
What's the interest of explain things in additionnal informations if people who review don't care of that? I clairly say it's a public place and people think it's private... I also clearly explain (in title!!!) it's a equestrian center. And an equestrian center is not a farm. So why do you reject that? You don't care of…
-
It's a place to practice sport. It's obvious. What kind of better photo? I don't see how the photo could be better... It's crazy to always ask for proof, especially when it's perfectly visible on google map... Do you ask for proof for a football ground? No. It's the same here, it's obviously an equestrian center and a…
-
Heu; no no no and no. Did you come to my village? NO This is a place for equestrian sports. It was built for that and only use for that. I explain that in description and this place is visible on Google map. It's crazy to say the opposite. I live in this village and i perfectly know what it is. Why do you say i lie in the…
-
No one built an installation like that on his private propriety. And that’s obviously not a farm. I don’t understand how i can show it’s not private or not a farm because it’s obviously not a farm or a private propiety on the photo (and on the description) There is no streetview here
-
That’s good modifications, but it’s only a step on the good direction. And there are still some problem (like trail marker rejections despite Ninatic clearly said Trail marker are acceptable). And the are also still good possibility to improve the system and allow more things in natural area. For games that request to walk…
-
That’s not a reason! wayfarer is a part of the solution to create wayspots in rural area. But Niantic should also autorize more thibgs to be a wayspot, especially in rural area to make their game playble everywhere. i think we can suggest some idea here. for example, i think there is something to do with natural features.…
-
All things i suggest have no sidewalk. That's in a village in France, and that's not a problem to get them validated. A sidewalk is not necssary to have a safe pedestrian acces in rural area.
-
Merci, ça me rassure de ne pas être le seul à comprendre les règles ainsi. 😀 (et tant mieux, car avec ce fonctionnement, y a vraiment moyen d'avoir des POI en pleine nature, ce qui manque cruellement (il est plus sympa de marcher en jouant en pleine nature plutôt qu'en pleine ville))
-
Completly stupid suggestion. This place don't need a sign, it's an obvious good POI.
-
By reading this forum, i'm sure, there is malicious intention behind rejections. Not for every rejection, but for a part of them there is. Why always think that a submission is a fake or abuse? All Niantic's game become better with more POI. So thinking everything is a fraud is a very bad idea... And reject something just…
-
J'ai lu ce topic, et c'est par ce topic que j'en suis arrivé à la conclusion que le caractère générique ne pouvait pas s'appliquer aux marqueurs de randonnées car c'est le chemin/sentier qui est évalué (et qui est donc forcément unique et non générique) . C'est dit et argumenté très souvent dans le topic. A partir du…
-
L'ancien café a été démoli, et la place a été construite à la place. C'est intéressant ton point de vue, si c'est à nouveau refusé, je virerais toute la description sur l'histoire du village, et me contenterais de présenter uniquement les outils agricoles exposés là (vu que les anciens outils agricoles passent^^). Mais…
-
Bah si les panneaux de sentiers sont valables dès lors qu'ils représentent un sentier de randonné et/ou qu'ils parcourent une forêt: Exemples de catégories de Wayspots Parcs et places Jardins Forêts Sentiers de randonnée Pistes cyclables Installations sportives dans des espaces publics Stades Terrains de sport C'est…
-
Je pose systématiquement la question en cas de refus de validation d’une proposition. Au final dans 90% des cas, c’est du rejet abusif parceque les gens ne respectent pas les règles de niantic. Les 10% restants étant valable mais améliorables. celà dit, ça ne me dit pas pourquoi en évaluant les propositions des autres, je…
-
Quand je regarde ma liste de propositions, j'en ai quelques uns: -Un ancien outil agricole exposé et entretenu par la commune, refusé la première fois accepté la seconde fois. -Les marqueurs de randonnées: souvent refusés, et pourtant explicitement éligibles (et j'en ai pas mal à évaluer d'ailleurs... Je les valide, mais…
-
J'ai le même problème que toi, après plus de 1300 propositions étudiées. Pas vraiment de solutions, j'ai surtout l'impression que le système est buggué. J'ai sans doute fait quelques erreurs (enfin... erreur, c'est vite dit vu le nombre de trucs qui collent aux critères mais qui sont refusés) , mais j'ai pas mal d'accords…
-
Or they can make the reviewing system faster. They can also improve the whole system to reduce the number of false rejections witch will likely be proposed again... They can drasticly reduce the number of submission by simply lock submissions in high density area (the time the queue decrease) They can also change the…
-
That's what i do. ;) The only thing is that i've wait many year before seeing a POI in my village, so i've already make the list since a long time, so it's a little frustrating to have to wait 14 days each time to nominate just a little part of the list. (and event more frustrating when something is rejected without good…
-
That's won't change anything. Having to wait just delay the moment where everything that can be a POI will be effectively proposed. That's also delay the moment we can make nominations on area without any stop (because the priority is where we live) and some potential POI will simply be ignored. (for example, when i see…
-
It's better than nothing, but i think it would be great if we can do more nominations...