Jtronmoore-PGO
✭✭✭✭✭
Jtronmoore-PGO ✭✭✭✭✭
Reactions
Comments
-
The last picture of the bridge is the best one since its more focussed on it. Glad it got accepted
-
Well for one street signs are 100% not eligible. I would atleast use something that may be eligible rather than a street sign
-
Hard no on the 1 upgrade= 1 wayspot thing.
-
I honestly hope you don’t believe submitting garbage like this is “worth the try”
-
Not really eligible imo. In your own words how does this meet eligibility criteria for it being a bike rack and a bike repair station?
-
Agreed with above^
-
Benches are normally not eligible unless the person its dedicated too is of cultural or historical importance to the community. Or if it is artistically unique. The one above doesnt look like it would be eligible Random sign with no information would not be eligible either
-
Jeeze that looks a little too good to be true in my eyes
-
In your supporting info you mentioned nothing about how this place is eligible. You mentioned everything to try and counter previous rejections. a google photosphere would help for the one rejection and possibly the other. Also I wouldn’t bother mentioning that it used to be a school as that has no relevance to what you…
-
Basically the same thing i said you just reworded it :)
-
Correct me if I’m incorrect someone. But, I do not believe College’s are inherently eligible anymore with the new criteria. The other rejection reason I see there is “does not meet acceptance criteria”
-
You should be able to bank your upgrades instead of it being automatically applied. I don’t think that you should be able to re-use an upgrade at all. Niantic has discussed that they may eventually have an appeal process for wrongly rejected nominations. Which is a much better alternative then endlessly resubmitting with…
-
If its a competition arena i can see it being eligible. Someone own farm they teach lessons? More than likely not
-
I would have rejected this as well as not meeting criteria
-
you can’t appeal a rejection so each upgrade is only good once. This would just open up for crazy abuse of people just resubmitting the same stuff and clogging the system without improving anything on there own end
-
1* other rejection/does not meet criteria
-
You should know not to orientate pff existing portals, i dont see how it meets any of the three criteria, and also under what makes a good wayspot: Transit stations A nod to the transportation industry, which also connects and unites people around the world Accept transportation hubs (like Grand Central Station), but not…
-
More often than not if the gym is deleted from the game its still a portal in ingress. Not sure if the cell would be blocked either if that was the case
-
You described everything but the bike in the supporting info
-
Its also rejected for not meeting criteria. Which in my opinion is correct
-
Agreed with above. Basically someone complained and it has removed the raid function. Be lucky they didnt lose the whole gym itself as I have seen happen before. ive seen park gyms that wont spawn raids more than likely because people living close to it complained. Even though in my opinion if you chose to live beside a…
-
Neither of these are really good candidates for nominations imo. A wooden path could be used for exercise yes but you still need a specific point to be able to anchor the poi to. So nominating an entire pathway like you did is not a good nomination. And if its actually a named trail use that and you would need to use…
-
Just because something is old does not mean it meets historic value criteria.
-
Not sure if this would be good enough to be accepted. However I don’t understand the reason behind the “@246” and “@this block” they almost seem like tags for me. It would probably meet exercise posibly. But also i would avoid using the word pokestop in supporting info. Also i would remove anything about restrictions or…
-
Its just a wrong rejection reason. Niantic by my knowledge has never came out and said something on a wrong rejection reason. Keep in mind 90% of people who submit a local business do a very poor job when filling out there description/supporting info. I rarely see a business nomination that someone actually puts in a…
-
Street signs generally fall under mass produced/ generic and are rejected under does not meet criteria. How ever an educational sign or possibly a sign for a park/beach or community information sign may be eligible. storm drains are usually not eligible. A painted plaque doesnt make something a mural. So in my eyes this…
-
If you think the place is eligible please dosome research on how the place is unique and use your description and supporting text wisely to really sell this poi to the reviewers. If its a hotspot show proof of that either using a travel guide site or even a rating off of one. Maybe list some of the bands that have played…
-
I don’t think they are talking about athletic fields in that little blurb you posted. More than likely talking about some other objects as they talk about athletic fields above it in the link and make no mention of multiple fields together. Thank you for the link though
-
We need to see description info and the supporting text, also knowing the rejection reasons as well. By looking at your supporting photo to me (without any additional info) it looks like its beside a farm
-
i have submitted camping grounds before with success (pre criteria update). I also had a nice sign for these campsites. I could see a campsite being a place to be social if you go camping with other friends and such though.