Maxyme99-PGO
✭✭✭✭✭
Maxyme99-PGO ✭✭✭✭✭
Reactions
Comments
-
Because it's a slider on the same hill than is existing POI. So it is a duplicate of the same location. You even take a photo in exact same angle, so it looks like a photo update for hill, not a new POI. But even if it wasn't a duplicate, I'm sure it's closer than 20 m from existing POI so it won't appear in any game,…
-
Thank you for posting it @LukeAllStars-PGO :) It's a shame that old mail didn't show real rejection reasons at that time (but I don't know how review process looked at that time so maybe it makes sense you only get examples for rejection). If mails were improved to show rejection list like that, but with real rejection…
-
I think you're missunderstandig something here. It's not about a corporation Crossfit chains gyms, it's about normal gyms that specialize in crossfit exercises. You even have a link it first post to the exact gym that was going to be nominated, and it's not a Crossfit corpopration gym. I'm not even sure if in many…
-
Oh, it might be the case here, thank you for this information :) I'll try to quote less and see if there's any difference :D
-
Not, it wasn't a post with any link or picture. I was just writing answer to someone, the only thing I did was quote other post from the same thread. But it also happened to my normal posts that wasn't even with quote, it was just normal reply in a thread. Maybe I'm really posting too much lately and it's considered a…
-
Yes, I got similiar problem with one post in "Nomination Improvement" - it was so long in review by mods I almost posted it second time when I saw it saved in comment box xD And I also think reviewing by mods got more frequent lately, or maybe I'm just posting more and more of my post is chosen to review :D
-
Sorry to tell you this, but it's only a small public part of ground with 3 benches (we can call it small square). There isn't anything eligible to be accepted. Benches aren't eligible (the exceptions are benches with a sign in honor of someone famous, but not all of them will also be eligible). If this place doesn't have…
-
I saw that too (it was in my thread :D ), and this mismatched post looks really weird. I don't know what's going on on forum, but we got some problems lately. I also don't like autosave, I had to delete my last saved comments from 3 threads I opened again, it's kinda confusing :/
-
Yes, you're right here too. I'm not really sure why mails from both games are so different, they should be almost the same (only game reference names should be different, like portals/pokestops etc.). In PoGo you have much more information what can be improved compared to Ingress rejection mail, and it's kinda weird that…
-
Thank you for posting this example :) So it looks like in both games rejection mails look a bit messy and can be confusing. I think changing it for a list with rejections would be helpful for everyone and it shouldn't be that hard thing to do. It's a small change, but it's really easy to see difference :)
-
My bad, I thought that I saw some with more rejection reasons. But I may be wrong :)
-
I'm not trying to argue with you about it location, I mentioned it because other people that posted here wrote they got this nomination to review and pin wasn't in place you got us in link but was mismatched a few meters away and because of that it was impossible to find it. I looked at your link and I had hard time to…
-
I'm not saying it's fake trail marker, but on such photo it doesn't look permament and looks like a sticker. Better angle on photo would make it look more real for sure, showing second trail marker that is on the same side would help too. This trail marker we see on main photo is very weird, because it doesn't fit in one…
-
I'm glad my explanation was helpful :) Oh, so it's some kind of a fountain :) Then it can be eligible, but you must show it better in your nomination. As FullFeeder-PGO mentioned, you must make main photo a bit further from it so it will be easier to recognize :) At first it doesn't look like you has this fountain visible…
-
Creo que incluso sin marca de agua no es una buena nominación. Parece un banco en el parque normal y simplemente no son elegibles. Intente nominar algo más, como parques infantiles, iglesias, monumentos, campos deportivos, etc. Lea los criterios qué es elegible y qué no, encontrará una lista de ejemplos de buenas…
-
I'm glad they're helpful :) And some answer to your answers :D 1) I saw your nomination in "Nomination Improvement", so I think fountains can be upgraded and they should be accepted. But you must improve this nomination, I wrote new post in your improvement thread (it was choosen to be moderated before posting so will be…
-
Did you get only one rejection criteria or more? You shouldn't focus only on one rejection criteria, some might been choosen by mistake or misclick. But as LukeAllStars-PGO wrote, it's not really eligible. If it's a real local hotspot and you can prove it is one, then it might have a chance, but without it's just not…
-
I will say this from the point of view of someone from another country: This doesn't look permament on first photo. I'm not sure how trail markers looks in your location, but this one I see on main photo looks like homemade sticker pinned with pins to this wooden post. From your support photo I can see that on this place…
-
It's hard to tell when we don't see your nomination. Make new thread in "Nomination Improvement" part of forum where you will post your full nomination (with screenshots that show both photos, all descriptions, location and screenshot of rejection mail), when we see it we can tell you why it could been rejected and how to…
-
You can also review other people nominations to get upgrade, so your nomination will be reviewed much faster. But you need to review more than 100 other nominations to get upgrade, because you need 100 agreements with other reviewers that reviewed the same nominations as you. It might take time for some of these…
-
First: This is not the correct part of forum for this, you should post it in "Nomination Improvement" part of forum, so people could help you improve it or tell you why it's not eligible. Second: Even if only one person misclick or just choose incorrect rejection criteria and 50 or more other persons choose "Not meet…
-
You can't withdrawn nomination that got "Upgrade" or "Upgrade next" next to the title. It just how it works. But even if you could withdrawn it, you won't get your upgrade back (or chance to nominate something else for it), your nomination would be wasted even if you withdrawn something. Next time try to talk with other…
-
If they're not too close to each other, then you can nominate both. But if they really are identical, then you must make really nice photos and descriptions for reviewers that they're not the same thing but with misplaced location. If you can't see both of them on map view or streetview, them you must make good photos…
-
Ok, so I checked this location, and on streetview this place is also closed, like in your both photos. If you want to have a chance for it being accepted you must take photos when it's open, not when it's closed, becasue when it's closed it really looks like garage for private house with a poster put on it to make fake…
-
Ok, that's weird you got only this rejection criteria, but I explained why it might be the case in my earlier post so I can't said much more about it. But it still a rejection, even if wrong reason was chosen on rejection list. As others mentioned, it was rejected because it doesn't met criteria. It's weird that you got…
-
As other mentioned, it doesn't look like something eligible for me. Even if something can be found on "What is it?" list, it doesn't mean it's eligible. Like Nadiwereb-PGO said, you can found on this list many other object that aren't eligible either (schools, items, animals), so being on "What is it?" doesn't make…
-
First, you can't appeal rejected nominations. This forum is for appeal existings POIs that should be removed because they're fake, in dangerous place or locations that they showed was demolished or moved somewhere else. You can also appeal here for POIs that was wrongly removed from game (some malicious players delete good…