Theisman-ING
✭✭✭✭✭
Theisman-ING ✭✭✭✭✭
Reactions
Comments
-
Im not at all convinced that either are street art and not just graffiti so would 1* both candidates without further proof
-
A picnic shed ? Thats what you believe meets criteria ? 1* instant reject, do not resubmit it its trash. If that is an information board in the support statement picture ? then that is a possibly a valid POI, but a picnic bench with a roof, not a chance
-
I've had and reviewed that exact POI, do you know what a Google search of Joyce Tallent Stoke Gifford turns up, a mention of a deceased estate and thats it. Nothing about what she did for the community, no local newspaper articles, absolutely zip to prove she was what you claimed and that this was nothing but a generic…
-
Thats not quite right If its a playground and all the equipment is all together then yes its one POI for the lot of them. However if items are at a "significant distance" from each other then they can also be accepted i.e. gym equipment or play equipment that has been spread out all over a park. The problem is "significant…
-
Should apply yes, however as defined by Niantic they are not classified as PRP, hence the issue that local laws regarding PRP must be taken into consideration
-
Its not a bug, it sounds like you need to re read the review criteria
-
Deleted due to ambiguity
-
All the games say "pay attention to your surroundings" if someone walks into traffic because they are to engrossed in a game then thats their own fault
-
I dont know about Italian law and buildings so I can't comment, but people on that thread asked for reinstatement of the POI as the property wasn't PRP. Are you saying it was ?
-
Ignoring your interpretation of that answer, as I don't agree with your take on that, local laws MUST be taken into account. In the UK we have terraced houses, they are PRP. There is no US equivalent of a Terraced house, the closest are Row houses and Town Houses, but neither are the same. Now under Niantics definition of…
-
Problem with tying it to a badge is that not everyone enjoys everything and getting agreements or something accepted is not always the easiest thing even for a top quality candidate. You'd be unfairly penalizing people for either not doing both games, or putting them at the mercy of others doing and hoping that the…
-
What ? NO NO NO NO NO Were not supposed to take into consideration that an image is going to be cropped when used in game. No one is meant to think, well this is going to be cropped so I'm going to take it like this. Niantic can use the images in anyway they see fit for different games etc, how they crop it and use it for…
-
The problem you've got is that most trial markers in the UK are disc shaped and that looks like a standard UK direction sign which normally says shops, town center etc. Theres no doubt its a valid POI and from what I can see off the support info you included a link to the website as well. Just resub and try again. If there…
-
Can you provide the rest of the details for your nomination as just going by the picture it looks like some light poles. If thats what it is then thats about the best you're going to get for a picture
-
If it was accessed via your PoGo account then submit an appeal through the PoGo help page
-
I think you're doing @LukeAllStars-PGO a disservice. I'd love to approve more local businesses but the majority of the submissions for them tend to be total garbage. The support statement generally says " unique hyperspot, local gathering place" or some other keyword, but doesnt give any proof , no web links, not even a…
-
Also bare in mind that even if it its a big chain it can still be important to the local community as a popular community gathering place. It is all location and situational dependant The example from Niantic was in the small town they were from the one coffee shop they did have was a chain one, but as it was the only one…
-
Welcome to the world of Niantic inconsistency. Niantic have in the past explicitly stated on the forums that we are to reject any and all new submissions on military bases, doesn't matter if it was a recreational are or not. However on the forums is only where they have stated this, they never amended the guidlines on the…
-
Where did they say that, because now your blatantly making stuff up
-
Apologies in advance for the crudely drawn pictures, put I think there is a misunderstanding of what people are on about. Take this as an example to try and clear things up Red is the property boundary Yellow is sidewalk The two blue lines are the road In this picture, the sidewalk is an easement, it goes across the…
-
Sorry whats not clear ? Instead of thinking of it as bike trail imagine its a road and a car. The road tself and any route directions while on the road aren't valid, so in this case any trail markers for a bike trail wouldnt be valid. However, on the road you may have services where you can pull in and a pedestrianised…
-
Have you got proof it is what you say it is, because it looks like a homemade display table. Is the laminated paper under it confirmation? As it would have been better to take a support picture of that or at least include those details in the support statement instead of going on about comparing windows If possible include…
-
Please try and read and understand "Unlike previous clarifications and small-scale changes, this is a complete overhaul of the criteria and overrides any previous AMA response or clarification here in the forum. The new criteria should be considered the new source of truth." It completely overhalls the criteria, an bridge…
-
What you've quoted is also why new POI's still appear on military bases, despite it being repeatedly reiterated on the forums by Niantic that they should be rejected. Then quote says "if it interferes with the operations of ...." The submissions in militarily bases that still come through are for things like statues,…
-
Reject and report as abuse
-
The AMA you've quoted is from October 2019, prior to the complete overhaul of the criteria in November 2020 which replaced any prior AMA. A generic bridge no longer meets any critera.
-
Picture looks fine, but without seeing the rest of the nomination I'm not convinced an appliance store is a worthwhile candidate so im assuming people rejected it and just choose poor picture as an easy to choose reason that doesnt require further writing
-
Ok, from the top Location : it's not listed on Google maps as a church, usually all churches have a church icon signifying where they are, this one doesnt have it. The address provided is correct and verifiable on Google search. Unfortunately I can't see where the pin was placed as its not show in your post. If it was in…
-
Friendly word of advice, dont post any more things like this if you don't want to get yourself banned and have your Wayfarer privilege revoked. Telling / asking people to accept just so you have more things to do can actually be classified as trying to influence reviewers. Thats actually one of reasons to mark a submission…
-
You're not meant to accept every single trail marker on a single trail if they look identical. The guidlines clearly state that an object needs to be visually unique, that means not having 10 trail markers for the same trail that look identical being accepted in the same area Niantic have always said and reaffirmed the…