Personally I would only consider VR (3*), E8R (5* never seen one), E7R (3*) and Gold Olympic Boxes (5*). The rest are just rubbish and it amazes me how many get through. A relatively new E2R one has … (View Post)

For me they are marginal. They don't really meet criteria. However you do occasionally get one that is so spectacular that I would pass on artistic merit as worthy of exploration. Your example does s… (View Post)

I reviewed this yesterday. I gave it 5*. My initial reaction based on just the photo was negative so I agree this is indeed a victim of lazy reviewing. I Googled the club and in my opinion it is a fa… (View Post)

That's not strictly true either is it? My interpretation of the latest guidelines is that footbridges can be eligible if they are part of a trail. Their eligibility is based on them being a fixed anc… (View Post)

I like this sort of idea. I was thinking of something similar myself. The way I would do it is when you get to 100 agreements you can choose either a nomination or an upgrade. I would imagine that th… (View Post)