ElwynGreygoose-ING
✭✭✭✭
ElwynGreygoose-ING ✭✭✭✭
Reactions
-
Re: Appeal: Golden Jubilee Commemorative Bench @ Riverview Golf Course
You say yourself that there are "countless" of these benches. No way would they ever get accepted. Which of the criteria do you think they would meet and why? (View Post) -
Re: How do I break the "Temporary or Seasonal Display" curse?
Well done for doing the research - but reviewers are not likely to do that. Instead, what reviewers will see in the photosphere is largely graffiti. The mural has been severely defaced with graffiti.… (View Post) -
Re: How do I break the "Temporary or Seasonal Display" curse?
That's graffiti, not a mural, and reviewers in my experience would judge that as temporary because it might get painted over at any time. It is vandalism, after all. (View Post) -
Re: Come one then. Tell me why this trail marker “does not meet criteria” when it does.
I don't think anyone rejects for lack of effort, but if a submission is lazy, careless and sloppy, then that throws doubt on such things as the location, which might otherwise merit 3*. There are man… (View Post) -
Re: Come one then. Tell me why this trail marker “does not meet criteria” when it does.
Wales Coast Path and Cotswold Way come to mind. Also they don't use detailed and unique titles, and no photospheres. A lot of room for improvement and then these would be guaranteed 5* instead of ins… (View Post)