I agree that the way to rate these is "would a new item be of interest to the local community" or "would it be missed if it disappeared". If yes, then it probably should score hig… (View Post)

The criteria remain the same for urban and rural areas. However for smaller communities I judge borderline nominations with a little more leeway, for example memorials to a 'notable person' - I try t… (View Post)

I think a lot of us would want to know what we did wrong, even when we have an overall great rating! My rating has been solid great except for a couple of weeks a few months ago when it rapidly dropp… (View Post)

If youth group means young people up to 25 like it usually does in my country then I think they can be eligible. However if aimed mainly at much younger children then it should be rejected for k12 (k… (View Post)

So why are people saying to apply their local laws to my reviews then? (View Post)