Search
-
URL as a proof
I've submit hiking trail marker and VTT trail marker (witch are supposed to be eligible, event without a name, according to Niantic's Rules) and get rejection for URL! Just because i proove theses markers are official marker with URL in additionnal information (that's how we are supposed to do...) So please clarify that:… -
Re: URL as a proof
Not in France. It’s the law. It’s totally forbidden to install trail marker on a private path. and there is no name on the majority of trail markers because the name is on the map… map witch are sold by IGN (so not on the internet). The only thing that exist on the internet is the link i give in additionnal information:… -
Re: URL as a proof
I agree. But i still think it would better to have 5% bad wayspot accepted rather than reject 30% of valide nomination just because there is a little doubt. i think the majority of people who submit things are not here to try to cheat the system. Especially for trail marker in rurual area. (There are plenty of trail… -
Re: URL as a proof
Niantic tend to think of only US-centric stuff with comments like; Also Niantic clearly said that there is no need a name to make a trail marker eligible In the UK, there’s thousands of “Public Footpath” markers that don’t have a name, and are not part of the same thing. It’s just an arrow to say you’re allowed to go that… -
Re: URL as a proof
Lots of points to address here but the bottom line is that reviewers can learn from rejections and improve their nominations. I now get 100% of trail marker nominations approved but only because it's taken me two years of trial and error to figure out what works and what doesn't. I'm all for something to be done so… -
Re: URL as a proof
Ok, good to know for UK. I never saw them, but i think that a sign witch indicate a public footpath is eligible according to the rules. It's very different from one country to an other. As i said, in France, the large majority of trail marker don't have a name on them (like those in the submission here... And… -
Re: URL as a proof
Yes, we can learn from rejection... only if theses rejections are totally legit and correctly explain. The problem with the rejection is that they don't follow the rules, so it's impossible to learn something from a rejection. Two examples: -I try to nominate 4 differents sign about nature. On of them get validated on the…
7 results