Single Art Installation of 600 Pieces

Review Support
1

I have a reviewing challenge that has come up more than once recently and I am not sure the right way to review it. The waypoint submissions are for individual art tiles part of a large installation called Words Over Water in a park lining a river/lake at Tempe Town Lake, Tempe, AZ, USA. The 600 unique tiles are placed over 6 linear miles of park. Many of these tiles are already stops in Pokemon Go and additional are regularly submitted. They are significant to the community as a whole, but I am not sure each one is significant.

I had initially denied the new stops I reviewed. I want to verify that would be the right call. Or, should I approve as they are technically unique, significant, accurately identified as part of Words Over Water, etc.

2

Is it possible to share more detail?

3

Sure! Let me know if there is something specific I can provide. Here are examples of already-approved waypoints:

1000266428
10002664281080×2424 242 KB

1000266429
10002664291080×2424 235 KB

The points I am being given to review look exactly like this, but the name reflects the tile content and the photo is of the unique tile.

These are photos taken at a distance. You can see that these tiles are inset into the barrier between the path and the water. Together, they are actually a book that tells a story.

1000266430
10002664301070×980 225 KB

This website describes the project

4

If these are individually placed tiles around a 6 mile area then I have no problem seeing them as distinct, so I’d be minded to accept. What a cool project! It would definitely make me want to explore the area