While the restaurant has been closed, the Inn itself is a historic structure.
Windsor Inn was constructed about 1832, possibly incorporating the earlier stagecoach stop. Historical accounts of the village attribute the present structure to William McKnight. Windsor, NJ was listed on the National Register of Historic Places in 1992.
I should have noted that I am not staff - just trying to help you with your appeal. If you have evidence that the Wayspot was for the historic structure and that the structure still exists and is being preserved, you should present that for them.