I had this nomination rejected about a month ago. It got pulled into internal review and got rejected, but didn’t give me any reason at the time. I thought that it was because they reviewed it as a bench, and not as a viewpoint, so for the first line of my appeal statement I put something along the …

exactly four months later it was accepted! [image]

Yes @elijustrying I’m reffering to scene as a whole. If it were so clear clarified, I think we don’t have any discussion about all the beautyful views. And I’m absolutly with you, that trailmarkers are similar to this.

No problem, I try to improve my wayfarer skills as well as my english skills.

Tausendmal besser als mein Deutsch.

:smiling_face_with_tear: [Screenshot_20240508-125344]

Thats sad :pensive: I really liked this submission, great for exploring I just had a boat hire business rejected on appeal this morning for not telling them that it is significant to the local community when I mentioned how it enables people to explore the river and see the wildlife… I thought that…

I’ve had a boat hire added by Hampton Court for the same reasons so makes no sense :confused: In the same way that on my way home home I’ll see 20 memorial benches that are temporary with no significance except to the family and friends of John Smith dearly beloved etc etc

[1000030975] [1000030976] [1000030977] I mean, tell me if there’s more I can do… we have tried so many times, and I really do think its eligible as a good place to explore and socialise I’ve also had the odd “no pedestrian access” which is funny since people actually live on the island, there’s…

Luck of the draw? [Screenshot_20240508-143105]

Guess I do have another appeal, could work through all 5 rejections of this place :sweat_smile: No, some are better than others so I may try 1 more and see if I can get it through Theyre all worded a little differently and I have one where the sun is out! Yay

Scenic viewpoint - is it good or nah?

Nomination Support

AliceWonder1511 May 8, 2024, 1:21pm 42

Schade

Forum Bug: Translation fails to detect source language properly

Topic		Replies	Views
Appeal Decision inconsistent with other accepted wayspots and criteria clarification General Discussion	24	350	April 24, 2026
Team please have a look: Scenic viewing point with bench declined by Appeals Team Nomination Support	9	295	April 13, 2025
Valid Memorial Park Trail Bench denial Nomination Support	45	489	June 3, 2025
Scenic bench view rejection Nomination Support	20	297	July 19, 2024
What it means placemarker sign? It this rejection Nomination Support	29	408	July 24, 2024

Scenic viewpoint - is it good or nah?

Related topics