I haven’t had any issues with my rating as of late; it’s at Great, and has been for awhile. The only other people I’ve seen say they have a bad rating are mainly new reviewers that need to take a better look at the criteria and wait for agreements to come in, as well as someone who was rejecting everything using Accuracy so they could leave a comment, and that’s not the best way to reject every nomination that doesn’t meet criteria.
There was an issue with ratings earlier this year, but that was resolved back in July, and confirmed here:
Now, the issue earlier this year has caused some to stop reviewing entirely, so there have been less reviewers in general, thus fewer agreements and disagreements coming in, which your rating is based on. So, a new reviewer may mention that their rating is Poor after doing 200 reviews, but they may only have 15 agreements currently. When we have encouraged them to take another look at criteria, as well as wait for more decisions to be made on what they have reviewed to come in, they do tend to see their rating improve.
I will note that I’m lucky these days if I get 1 upgrade every 2 weeks; I used to get about 1 upgrade per week. There is a large number of edits in queue right now due to the edits challenge, and those don’t could towards agreements, so there could be a slowdown on agreements for awhile.
I’m still following the criteria, making my best judgment, and not rushing my decisions, and yes, I’m at Great. I really haven’t changed how I review, and for most who have been reviewing for awhile, I haven’t heard any issues since the fix in July.