That seems like a lot of accepted compared to rejected. Go back and review the Criteria and Help sections on the Wayfarer site, and be sure that you are expanding the tool tips in the review flow. I know it feels bad to reject things, but you need to make sure that you are reviewing per criteria, not heart.
Also, back when this current review flow was new, they told us:
So if you are just marking 
on the last three criteria questions, you may be accepting the nomination. They have never verified this either way. We have been given the example of a lamp post as something that would not be “Distinct” in its environment, so you may want to start using that as a rejection reason if you aren’t already.
Don’t be afraid to use “I don’t know” as the answer to the questions. That is a valid response.
If you just don’t know how to review something, you can skip. We have 100 skips now, each on a 24 hour counter. Do take your time and try to review something before you decide to use a skip on it. Skips do not hurt your rating, but skipping through too quickly might give you a cooldown where you can’t review for a certain time period. We aren’t exactly sure about that.