Hi Here you can discuss the collection of new rejection reasons .

Private property can be a rejection reason if it’s a single family private residential property or farmland. That has been clarified here: [image] Private Residences, Farmland & K-12 Criteria Clarification Collection Single-family private residential properties (SFPRP), …

It has been clarified again and again however I agree that this wording needs to be described better as it is very confusing. [image] [image] It feels like a step back from the guidance included in the tooltip. Both “private property” and “publicly accessible” have niche interpretation in Wayfa…

I’m not confused, as for many private properties, it’s considered trespassing to enter them without permission in many areas of the world. I see the “not publicly accessible” as being similar to trespassing here. The key word is “not,” as in the public shouldn’t access unless given permission to. …

[image] Por que fue marcado duplicado? General Discussion Buenas tardes, por que votaron por duplicado? Siendo que son publicaciones nuevas? Son un buen lugar para poque paradas [1000364273] [1000364274] [1000364272] [1000364271] As an example for duplicate

Yes, you and most of the forum regulars. To the ones that will get this as an introduction to the rejection criteria, those will be impacted. Trespassing is entering without permission, the nature of the property (public or privately) does not erase that. A private property can be publicly accessib…

[image] Why rejected Nomination Support [Screenshot_20250405-133853_Chrome] Why this is rejected As an example for ML rejection

[image] cyndiepooh: I think the original rejection was “Temporary/Seasonal or Not distinct,” but I didn’t seem to have made a note of it anywhere, because why would I? But now no rejection reasons will come up for that one, no matter how many times I refresh. [image] This one is indeed now…

When they attempt to combine two completely different concepts into one decision point it makes for an epic failure. It doesn’t matter that you could parse the words to support previous criteria. The fact that they’re using imprecise wording in an attempt to get double duty from a single codicil i…

This is what I meant. I know single family homes, farms are appropriate rejection reasons. I have had HOA park signs that say “private property” rejected because things like this rejection reason confuse everyone. My neighborhood is allowed to use that park so it should not be rejected even though …

Ok, explaining the HOA park with this rejection reason makes some sense now. Explaining how something that meets criteria could be rejected as private property by some makes it more clear. I’m also not a big meme person, and yes, most these days make no sense to me.

Discussion about new rejection reasons

General Discussion

AliceWonder1511 April 5, 2025, 9:33am 27

As an example for ML rejection

Topic		Replies	Views
Rejected always Nomination Support	54	816	January 9, 2026
Mysterious Interpretation of Criteria Review Support	35	465	July 8, 2024
Rejected for no reasons Nomination Support	19	340	May 22, 2026
Nominations being marked as mismatched location or temporary even tough they aren't General Discussion	46	918	December 13, 2024
Recent String Of Frustrating Rejections Nomination Support	41	689	April 29, 2026

Discussion about new rejection reasons

Related topics