When reviewing I use my best judgement. I will try to find opinions and preferably feedback from one of the Niantic reps if I come across something that is a “grey area” but because these replies seem to get fragmented in multiple threads at times it is not the easiest thing to find at times.
I will say that there seems to be a cultural or local difference between different areas. Simple example that I would use if estate signs here in Ireland. When growing up here and meeting friends and in later year if going to a bar or an event together we would normally always meet at “the head of the road”. The head of the road would be the estate name plaque.
Some of them are just cast iron plate with the estate name on it. More recently over the past few years they have become a little more up to date, or better looking with the likes of engraved stones, planters, metalwork.
The original premise still applies though. They are still “The head of the road” and are still used as a meeting point.
They might not pass all the time as probably to a lot of people the might look plain or generic but I can just rely on my own experience growing up and still to this day that they were/are a great place to socialise as I spent hours with friends sitting or standing around these estate/road names chatting, joking around and messing when younger and as we got older we still meet or collect friends in our cars now at “The head of the road”.
There are a lot of things like this I come across when reviewing that I apply my own experience to and use my best judgement.
At the end of the day, all we can do is use our own experience and best judgement of the core criteria. Obviously based on my example above this could be completely different in other countries so if it is, It won’t be agreed with but here it is what it is and I try to give a true and fair response when reviewing.
Because Wayfarer covers so much of the world it is extremely difficult for a hard fast set of criteria because of local nuances like my example above.
Opinions are just that, everyone has one. Some will agree with them, some won’t but, it can at times, not always, give a new train of thinking or open a persons eyes to something they may not be aware of. If there is no clarification from a Niantic rep then best judgement is all you can use.
I generally stick as close to the main criteria as I can and unless I have found a clear clarifcation from a Niantic Rep then I go with core criteria and best judgement. However, and this is probably the case with everyone. My own experience will differ from others so the criteria will always be a little skewed.