皆さんこんにちは。日本人です。
今まで100件以上申請してきましたが、エミリー審査によって承認されたのはレストランの一件のみ。
Googleのストリートビューから確認できるものであり、一般的にアクセスできます。にも関わらずサークルベンチやガレージアートなど全部否認。ただ申請数が減るだけでエミリー審査は何の役にも立ってません。何が足りないのか教えて欲しいです。
Googleのストリートビューがない場所でもあまり承認されてる事例があるみたいで、Googleのストリートビュー無くても評価に影響はないと思います。
写真を撮る位置が近すぎるのか？機械学習、エミリー審査とはなんなのか？承認を貰えるコツがあったら教えて欲しいです。
Do you know the reason why it was rejected?
Regardless of whether the review was done by ML or a reviewer, you should review the results to understand why it was rejected.
You can view the reason for rejection by going to “Manage Posts”.
1 Like
エミリー審査による否認理由は全て同じです。
不承認基準、wayfarer基準、としか書かれません。
タイトルや説明、など否認理由の詳細を書いてくれないのです。
Emily at Machine Learning is a program that makes decisions about acceptance, rejection, and delegation to the community based on the results of the community review process that has been accumulated so far. Perhaps the primary use in that decision is image patterns. It is likely that the decision is based on whether the place is suitable for socializing, exercise, or exploration, or whether it fits one of these three eligibility criteria.
Now, I would like to specifically mention the circle bench shown. It may sound harsh, but in NianticWayfarer, a resting place with benches placed under a squared arbor, pergola, or gazebo that serves as a roof to block out the sun has been considered a suitable place for socializing because we can talk with acquaintances outdoors for a long time. However, circle benches were not considered suitable places, even if they were planted to block the sun. Emily does not accept the circle bench because it is an accumulated judgment of the community.
Next is that illustration of the shutters with white lines on a black background, which many reviewers would accept as art. However, some reviewers, taking a harsher viewpoint, may decide that it is a commonplace sign for a store. If the store is important to the community or has a very distinctive business, it may be better to apply with that business. Local businesses can apply not only for cafes, restaurants, and other places suitable for socializing, but also for places suitable for exploring if the store sells a distinctive product, and I have applied for and been accepted for such a Wayspot.
Even if your application is rejected by Emily, you can use the appeal process to have your application reviewed again by the Wayfarer team. I am sure you will not be happy with the result, so why not defer to them? It may seem harsh and cold. But since you are going to be standing still for a long time, I have given you my honest opinion. Sorry.
2 Likes
回答ありがとう。
少し上の背景も入れて撮ったほうがいいですか？
確かにこの画像は近すぎるかもしれません。
ちなみにここはショッピングセンターの前のサークルベンチで、さらにここの通り沿いは屋台のキッチンカーが営業されているスペースでもあります。飲み物や食べ物を片手に休憩されてる方がいるのでそれも説明に記載したのですが否認でした。確かに日本は今真夏ですが、どちらかというと目の前のクーラーの効いたショッピングセンターに居ることを優先するかもしれませんね。でも気温が落ち着けばきっと交流が出来る場所として最適でしょう。少しエミリー審査は一般審査より厳しいのが現状だと感じてます。
日本ではこういうサークルベンチでも、評価は高いです。
シャッターアートは、すぐ近くに出店している本屋の一部の事務所です。そのような記載をしたのですが否認でした。
I suppose that Emily keeps track of candidates that have been rejected once. If you reapply and the image, location, description and additional information approximates that image, it will probably be detected and rejected.
If you are going to re-photograph the image, please inspect the image thoroughly as it is a high-traffic area. The image of the circle bench shows a child’s face, albeit small. Please look closely at the red circle slightly to the right of the top center of the image.
However, I am going to be harsh and say that I would not approve that circle bench if I were to review it. The first thing to consider in determining whether it meets the eligibility criteria is for what purpose the property manager has installed, managed, maintained, and preserved the object of the nomination. I would assume that the circle bench is being installed so that pedestrians shopping or otherwise can take a break. I don’t quite get the intent of installing them for chatting. I don’t see the shutter art as so negative, but similarly, some people may not feel that it is an appeal to the store’s business and is painted as art that they want many people to notice.
Once again, I don’t think Emily would miss the same nomination. I suggest you use the appeal(申し立て) to get the Wayfarer team to re-examine it.
1 Like