Hi Here you can discuss the collection of new rejection reasons .

Added, thanks! I’ve taken the french original, if you see someone posting the english version please let me know

I think we have seen them all by now. I love the new one that clearly tells you it was rejected by the “automated process”. That gives us something to work with on the presentation of the the nomination. But for the rest, why don’t they simply tell us what rejection reasons reviewers chose? That wo…

Yes I do think so too. If they don’t add a new one that should be all. But I think that they’re doing exactly what you’re suggesting, taking what have been choosen. Only at reason #15 and #21 I’ve some doubts. But if I remember correctly there’s the opportunity to give “more” feedback (do someone r…

I specifically have problems with this, which seems to indicate “Generic business” was chosen: [image] and this which we seem to see when “third party photo” is chosen: [image] We can’t even reject for this, so when does this appear? Niantic in house review? [image] I really want to know what …

The following is only assumption time by Alice, not given facts!: #1 is not distinct (however they separated them) #6 I’d guess is when you choose accuracy no → abuse → last point. Here it’s in german: [Screenshot_20250519_182046_Chrome] Ok #18 I’ve found nothing relatable but #21 could be accu…

[Screenshot_20250519-234903_Gallery] [Screenshot_20250519-234856_Gallery] Here u go. Honestly i am baffled

[image] AliceWonder1511: #1 is not distinct (however they separated them) I don’t believe so. The nominations I have had rejected for this reason have been exercise businesses. They have been appealed and accepted and I can’t show you that now. But this one (which has been accepted with a dif…

were these community decisions?

Yes it stays assumptions. It has ever been a problem to reject for being “generic”. Generic business or temporary / not distinct?

Discussion about new rejection reasons

General Discussion

TjoeMi May 19, 2025, 4:49pm 76

Here u go. Honestly i am baffled

According to appeal staff, natural features are rejection criteria again

Rejection reasons follow up thread

Topic		Replies	Views
Rejected always Nomination Support	54	773	January 9, 2026
Mysterious Interpretation of Criteria Review Support	35	455	July 8, 2024
Rejected for no reasons Nomination Support	19	331	May 22, 2026
Nominations being marked as mismatched location or temporary even tough they aren't General Discussion	46	899	December 13, 2024
Recent String Of Frustrating Rejections Nomination Support	41	632	April 29, 2026

Discussion about new rejection reasons

Related topics