I don’t think 1958 is necessarily that historic, although the 3 generations running it is a lovely story. It’s good that you included the newspaper story
Since a bakery isnt a place to socialise (unless you can eat there? Are there tables inside?) or exercise, you’d be looking to submit this as a place to explore, so I would focus on how this bakery could stand out from other bakeries - do they have a specialist product or a particular way of baking that is something unique?
Your appeals are on a timer for every 15 days, so you can appeal later if you wish.