Please restore the Wayspot that was unlawfully removed by Niantic "Knotenpunkt Radwege Schillerstraße - Hinterweilerstraße"

When submitting a Wayspot Appeal, make sure to include as much of the following information as possible:

  • Wayspot Title: Knotenpunkt Radwege Schillerstraße - Hinterweilerstraße
  • Location (lat/lon): 48°27’43.5"N 9°05’30.7"E
  • City: Gomaringen
  • Country: Germany
  • Screenshot of the Rejection Email (do not include your personal information): I didn’t get no information before removal of teh wayspot!
  • Additional Information (if any): Why are regular Wayspots being removed by Ninatic? The Wayspot can also be found on Google Maps (and Street View).


Hi,

There are no notifications of removals, this is not a function that is offered.

Furthermore, your Wayspot is a directional sign, not an actual trail marker. These would not be allowed to be accepted under this clarification:

A common confusion in Germany, actual cycling trails would be equipped with additional signs and logos.

As I visited Hong Kong many other “signs” where also accepted. But I agree, we are living on a countryside and not in a big city, So it is our fault that we have not the chance to play this game in the same manner like in a big city.

In Germany, we can also select direction signs when we want to suggest a new Wayspot. Why is this now confusing and unacceptable? (I don’t understand Ninatic’s logic.)
If you are right, then please correct the selection list so that we can only select what you accept. Thank you very much.

the category list is not a criteria list, the items there are unrelated to any of the Wayfarer rules

Even the Hong Kong Wayspots were also accepted with some simple direction signs, but this is in the city…

It is neither fun nor sensible to watch the system gradually remove wayspots that have been in place for eight years. Even historic buildings…

You have posted about one specific wayspot and been given a reasonable explanation as to why it has been removed.

If there are other wayspots which have been removed and you don’t understand why, you are welcome to post about them here.

If you find something removed that you disagree with, you could post the other examples as well., Histroic houses can be good candidates but dissqualified if they are a Single Family Private Residential Property. If it is such a property, it doesn’t matter how long it was a Wayspot before

Just because elsewhere decisions are made, doesn’t mean they are correct there either

If I understand correctly, Niantic can simply interpret the criteria as it sees fit?
For some, these bike path signs are accepted because they are part of a route and contribute to movement, exploration, and cultural themes.
For others, they are not accepted because they are “simple bike path signs”?
Then why are there criteria and a selection list?
I can provide an explanation for every Wayspot submitted that meets at least one of the criteria. But someone at a desk (far away from me) says that this is not the case and rejects it. Is that the point of the game, or is it the movement? (Pokémon Go)

Wayspots sometimes get accepted by the community despite being strictly ineligible.

If someone subsequently reports a wayspot, Niantic will sometimes remove it, despite it being accepted by the community. @kawin240 gives a good example of when this might happen - a wayspot on single-family private residential property (SFPRP) will get removed when reported. What the wayspot is of does not matter here - what matters for SFPRP is where it is.

Please forget the selection list. It has absolutely no meaning to any player of any Scopely game or to any wayfinder. All it does it gather data for Scopely and cause confusion for people submitting wayspots.

2 Likes

I understand, but I can see that you don’t understand our difficulties in the countryside, which is a shame.
I wish you all the best, as it’s slowly becoming pointless to play here (without Wayspots or arenas).

Please have a read through Please Reevaluate Wayfarer Criteria for Rural Areas

There are often comments from players who say they are in rural areas and are having trouble finding things to submit. This thread contains a discussion about this and suggests for what would be eligible.

Sometimes people find there is more than they expected.

Please note that lots of things are different in the countryside than in urban areas. Shops are further away, schools are further away, hospitals are further away and lots of things are harder to get to. Pokemon Go is not unique in being a different experience in rural areas than busy inner-city areas.

(Also, suburban areas can be surprisingly empty of interesting things, so players there sometimes have similar problems with playing on their doorstop.)

It’s sad to read something like this. It means that we could lose all our Wayspots in the future because no one can give us any proof that our Wayspots will still exist in the future. Similarly, it makes little sense to explain that a bicycle sign in the countryside has a different meaning than in the city, where every trash can has graffiti and is accepted!

In our small community, we have lost about 30% of our Wayspots and Arenas in the last two weeks. This also includes the routes that you can follow to reach a destination.

Is that fair?

Hallo,
hattest du dir die Kriterien zu Trails und Markers durchgelesen, die hier verlinkt wurden? Die zulässigen Markierungen für Fahrradstrecken sind die quadratischen drunter, zb die hier:

Das wären in der Nähe zum Beispiel die Streuobsttour, die Literatur-Tour für Kinder

ok, danke. Dann muss ich mal nach solchen Zusatzschilder Ausschau halten.

Gibt es sonst noch Möglichkeiten Wanderrouten oder andere Routen als POI aufzunehmen?

Ja genau, Markierungen für offizielle Wanderwege sind sehr gute Spots! Ich hatte bei einem anderen Thread mal was verlinkt. Die Gomaringer Rundwege, Wege von Früchtetrauf und Schwäbischer Albverein sind zb super

Hier gibt es die zulässige Markierung anscheinend, also einfach ein Closeup Foto von der Markierung machen und einreichen. Der Wayspot Knotenpunkt Hinterweilerstraße Härtenstraße und Stockacherstraße 48.463961,9.090688 scheint an der falschen Stelle zu sein, ich würde den auf jeden Fall berichtigen und dann ein aktuelles Foto der Wegmarkierung hinzufügen


Danke für die tollen Tips.

Wir bekomem ich denn den Verein als POI eingetragen, das müsste doch auch zulässig sein?

Hanoi, hkät ihr koi Wanderwege in Gomaringen?

Also das ist schwierig weil der Gustav-Schwab-Stift selber ja schon ein Wayspot ist und der Verein so wie ich das beurteilen kann kein richtiges Vereinsheim oder so etwas hat. Vielleicht sind im Gustav-Schwab-Stift noch mehr gute Wayspots wie zb die besagte Cafeteria


Oder vielleicht diese schöne Holzbrücke?