Would you accept a street sign?

1000013348

http://www.covenanter.org.uk/queensferry_covenanter_lane.html

The Covenanters were part of the political and religious reformation in Europe and the UK opposed to Catholicism and James VI and Charles I doctrines of the divine right of Kings which the Stuart monarchy believed placed them at the pinnacle of the church.

In the mid 17th century thousands of Scots signed the National Covenant( Covenanters) after Charles I attempts to impose a common book of prayer on people which led to Covenanters executed for treason, imprisonment in Greyfriars Kirk which is now seen as one of the worlds first concentration camps , riots and Jenny Geddes throwing a stool at the minister in the Kirk( church).

These events were the catalyst to the Bishop’s War, War Of The Three Kingdoms which the first and second English Civil Wars were part of, Cromwell, Irish Confederate Wars, Anglo- Scottish war ( third civil war), abolition of the monarchy, beheading of Charles I, restoration of the Stuart monarchy and eventually ending in the glorious revolution which saw Protestants William of Orange and Mary Stuart overthrow Catholic James Stuart II

The lane is named after the Covenanters caught here who had the signed Queensferry covenant which is kept over the road in the museum.

Anyway
 Would you accept a street sign?

3 Likes

That seems like it must more than meet whatever the bar is.

1 Like

This post reminds me of a scene from the movie Infamous (the Truman Capote biopic with Toby Jones).

In it, he is at a social event and he is trying out different ways to tell a scene in a book, seeing which gets the reaction he wants before committing to it. Test screening if you will.

Not a criticism, mind you. Just what it reminded me of.

2 Likes

I suspect that slope is a particularly slippery one. :wink:

Let’s go for a slide!

1 Like

I actually reviewed something very similar this morning :eyes:

I’ve forgotten the details but it was a standard street sign on a new build estate, and the name was inspired by the history of the area. The person had made an effort as they provided good background information. But it was just a street sign. So I voted to reject on that basis.

There is often a lot of interesting information about a place that doesn’t have a nice information board or a building that allows that information to come out.
I guess the interesting question - is there any reason that a map that focuses on objects should want more general information attached to it?
If yes what is a reasonable anchor on the map for that information?
I don’t think a standard street sign is ( being boring and not going down the slippery slide😂)

1 Like

I would not. This information is fascinating. But once you start diving into local history, you realize that most streets are named after someone or something significant.

2 Likes

I come down balanced top-dead-center on this kind of nomination.

Virtually every town in the US has named a street after, say, JFK or Martin Luther King. Most of them lack any special connection to the named individual. The special relationship needs to be made clear. Then I’ll accept it.

A detailed plaque is a particularly good, concise focus point for commemoration, but it is not a requirement.

I think our work should lead to more and better recognition of the stuff that makes places significant. Your discourse on The Covenanters aligns with this ideal.

Why not accept this sort of nomination, educate yourself and your fellows, and add to the virtual world?

Perhaps the ‘real world’ will catch up later.

1 Like

Picnic table overlooking the stoopid old bridge instead it is then.

1 Like

Yes but @frealafgb and I could meet at the picnic table and admire the bridge and wonder what the Covenanters would have made of it all.
That is some awesome picnic table.

1 Like

Speaking of standard street signs
 this one went live recently:

At least they made sure to address each arrow:

A few miles north east of this sign you can find a great place to visit. You can ice skate or watch the San Jose Giants play in their stadium next door. And just a street over you can visit the Japanese Friendship Garden, step back in time in San Jose Historic Park or visit the Happy Hollow Zoo. Continue east on Curtner then go left on Senter Rd. You cant miss it!

The street sign, studio and picnic area are all in the same cell so I’ll wait and see if Emily is being a bit crabbit with this first.

Before this

2 Likes

I tavoli da picnic o aree picnic Emily ve li valuta?? Perché nella città dove sono io (ne ho richiesti 8/9) non me ne ha valutati neanche uno.

These have all been Emily. I have a few more too

Wow, Emily only really likes my photo submissions. Rarely takes any “full” submissions anymore.

These all look so good :smiling_face_with_three_hearts:

1 Like

These are all Emily recently plus about another 6 in September.

I wouldn’t think it’s area related as two of those are in Kingston

1 Like

Emily didn’t even want these! I think she doesn’t like me.


2 Likes

Not yet anyway, maybe it will still grab them?

They both look fantastic and easy accepts.

1 Like

Maybe, but I think she’s avoiding me.

The heart is probably going to be lightship only or maybe ingress as well, but basically I wont be able to edit it if/when it goes live. It has an info board next to it with more detail, maybe Emily would have taken that, but the PoI should have a picture of the item, not the boring sign about it. So I wanted to submit with the best possible picture rather than the “easy accept” picture. I put the sign board as the supporting picture instead. I really like the project- turning reclaimed knives into art

I REALLY hope the mural is accepted. But reviewers dont like things that are inside. So I remain sceptical.

1 Like

No, as said elsewhere - many streets are named after historically significant people, groups or events. That having been said, I’ve seen a few sneak through.

Sometimes the street name signs include a brief history on or near the sign itself which might be eligible.