Is there any way to see feedback on the Disagreements with my reviews, or to at least see how many nominations I have personally accepted, rejected, or marked duplicate? I have only been reviewing for a couple of weeks, but my rating has dropped to Fair, and even after multiple reviews of the rules and criteria, I don’t even know if I am being too strict and literal with rejections, or being too lenient on acceptances?
You can’t see your disagreements, but your profile will show those other numbers
Dropping to “Fair” happens to a lot of new reviewers. I think it is just that each disagreement affects the total more if you are new.
What usually works to get that rating back up is to go slow on each one, and don’t try to do too many too quickly. Read the tool tips for each question, and don’t be afraid to use “I don’t know” when you don’t know for sure. That is a valid reply. We get a lot of skips now, so if the nomination is just too confusing to decide, Niantic has said that skipping (or timing out) will not hurt your rating.
There is usually someone online if you have a specific review you want to ask about. But there is a lot of gray area in Wayfarer where you have to use your own judgement.