Bad decision by the appeals team


This painted power box was rejected by reviewers for “not likely to be permanent”, which is ridiculous, so I appealed it, and the decision of the appeals team is even more ridiculous.


It is “a regular painting that is non-artistic”. Hoo boy, we got some art critics on the appeals team!

This painted power box is commissioned by the city as can be read in this article: Walls with Paint: Traffic Lights | This is Eindhoven

It’s clearly in the same style as the first picture in the article and most likely painted by the same commissioned artist. I see no reason why this should have been rejected by reviewers in the first place, but I ESPECIALLY don’t see why the appeals team is blundering like this.

1 Like

Hi @GeneralSecura
I’ve edited your title to a little less inflaming one.

1 Like

Can you share whats written in supporting text in the original submission?

Can you show which picture are you talking about here?

Do you have any evidence that this is commissioned by the owner of the junction box? If not, I can’t see a reason why it should be approved… but am willing to be convinced otherwise.

1 Like

For those who may not like to click links, this is clearly in the style featured in the article

This is an awesome project featuring named artists and I would approve each work. I wonder if the word “test” in this particular article is why it was rejected as temporary? Do you have other articles you could link?

4 Likes

No other info sources to my knowledge, but if they reject a submission made in 2025 because an article from 2020 mentioned the word “test”, that’s just lousy reviewing. Especially since this particular power box has looked like this since at least October 2022 according to StreetView photos. Seems to me that’s permanent enough.

You mean like the article I already linked that leads to the city’s official news/events/tourism website?

And if you think only commissioned works are valid wayspots, then I suggest you read the criteria clarification again. Nowhere does it mention being commissioned as a requirement. It’s a plus, not a must. Unique Art

I still cant see how this considered to be “same style”

That’s a you problem then. @cyndiepooh clearly sees it.

Apology. I missed the link. My eyes weren’t fully awake. In terms of it being commissioned, I see it as added weight to it being accepted more than anything else.

1 Like

i will confess that i actually didn’t see that the link was in the original post either - i had pulled up the screenshot and used google lens to pull it from there. felt a little silly when i realized i didn’t have to do that. idk why my eyes wanted to run past that.

1 Like

I won’t play the Dyslexia card on this one. I genuinely wasn’t fully awake when I saw the post.

1 Like